William Katz:  Urgent Agenda

HOME      ABOUT     CONTACT 

 

 

 

 

A POSSIBLE ELECTORAL BOMBSHELL – AT 8:52 A.M. ET:  Silvio Canto Jr. alerted us to this.  It is a growing story with profound implications.  From the New York Sun: 

Hang on to your hats, New Yorkers. That’s the word in the wake of this week’s decision of the United States Supreme Court to take a new look at the meaning of the constitutional mantra of “one man, one vote.” It could ignite an earthquake in American politics.

The case — known as Evenwel v. Abbott — is arising from Texas. It’s about whether voting power has to be apportioned equally by general population or by eligible voters. The impact could extend way beyond the Lone Star State, shifting political power away from cities.

Particularly cities with relatively high, non-voting immigrant populations like — oh, say — New York. The case has the potential to require authorities to strip away during the redistricting process population that isn’t eligible to vote — undocumented aliens, felons, children.

Edward Blum is the conservative constitutional sage who heads the Project on Fair Representation, which provided counsel in this case. He tells me the Nine could force redistricting. The court could, he said, “help upstate New York districts dramatically.”

Not just upstate. Mr. Blum reckons the case could lead to changes in city councils, too. He speculates that council districts in such big cities as New York, Houston and Chicago are among the “most mal-apportioned” in the country.

And...

Slate.com is already suggesting that a victory by Mr. Blum’s clients — two Texas voters who feel under-represented — could mean “more Republican districts.” This is because most states apportion districts based on total population, which, Slate says, “includes noncitizens, children, felons and others ineligible to vote.”

The riddle the case attacks was left unsolved by the series of Supreme Court cases known as the one-man-one-vote decisions.

COMMENT:  We certainly will be following this case closely.  My own guess is that the Court will be very reluctant to change the current system because the negative impact will be greatest on cities – in other words, minorities.  But you never know.  I'm also guessing that Justice Kennedy will break a tie on this one.

May 28,  2015